The Story of a Timeless Home
Every great Key West home tells a story, and 616 Eaton Street’s begins more than a century ago. Built in 1911, this grand Old Town residence stood quietly among the palms, weathering generations of island life. Over the years, its bones remained strong, but time had faded its original beauty. Then came a vision, a promise to breathe life back into the property while honoring its history. That vision became reality between 2022 and 2024, as a team of craftsmen, architects, and designers brought the home into a new era without losing the soul that made it special.
Rebirth Through Design
Architect Haven Burke of Bender & Associates and builder Jordan Holtkamp of Holtkamp Construction led the transformation, crafting a masterpiece that feels both classic and new. Step inside and the air feels different; warmer, richer. Thanks to the reclaimed heart pine floors sourced from the historic Florida Biltmore Hotel in Tampa. The light glows through restored windows, dancing across tall ceilings and timeless millwork. Every space feels intentional, from the open living room to the offices that frame the home’s heart with quiet sophistication.
A Home That Breathes
The kitchen is more than a place to cook, it’s the soul of the house. A wall of glass opens to the outdoor dining pavilion, blurring the line between inside and out. Pass-through windows are perfect for entertaining from the pool deck, where guests gather with cocktails in hand. This is a home designed for living, not just admiring.
Beyond the main house, two guest cottages embrace the saltwater pool like loyal companions. Each structure, crafted with the same care and precision, offers a retreat for friends and family. The rear guest house even hides a 1,512-square-foot attic, a space brimming with potential for the next chapter of this ever-evolving estate.
A Private Sanctuary in the Heart of the Island
Step outside and you’ll understand why this address is so coveted. The lush gardens, shaped by landscape architect Mike Flaugh and brought to life by Jason Lloyd of Indigenous Landscape, surround you in quiet privacy. The only sounds are the trickling water of the pool and the distant hum of Old Town life just two blocks away. Here, luxury isn’t loud, it’s effortless.
The Legacy Continues
616 Eaton Street isn’t just a home. It’s a conversation between past and present, a living example of what happens when craftsmanship, creativity, and respect for history come together. Every inch tells the story of Key West itself, vibrant, enduring, and full of life.
If you’ve ever dreamed of owning a piece of Key West’s history reimagined for today’s world, this is it.
Who You Work With Matters,
THE SPOTTSWOOD TEAM
Terri Spottswood, John Spottswood, Ted Stewart
305-432-4848
[email protected]
Truman & Co. Real Estate
